( For DTC & e-commerce founders selling physical products, $300K to $1.5M a year )

Find What’s Turning Your Brand Into a Commodity.

Cheaper copies are pulling you into discounts. This 15-minute scorecard shows the signals telling buyers to compare you on price, and which leak to fix first.

Read the transcript ↓

Line up eight competitor pages. Six in sage green. Five in the same rounded font. Seven offering 15% off for your email. Following the herd is expensive. I’m a llama in a lilac visor, and nobody has ever mistaken me for the alpaca next door. Your store? Let’s find out.

Picture it. 9:02 PM on a Tuesday. Five tabs open. Meta: cost per purchase $52.40. ROAS down from 3.2 to 1.9. TikTok Shop: a copy of your product, running your slow-pour video, shot for shot, for $24. Yours is $52. And in Klaviyo drafts, a campaign called WEEKEND20. Last time you ran it, 38% of that weekend’s orders used the code. Your cursor is on Schedule.

You’ve probably already paid to fix it. An ad agency. A conversion sprint. An email agency. Each one fixed the thing they sell. None of them answered the one question a buyer asks with two tabs open: why is this one worth $28 more?

That’s an upstream problem. When your page makes the same claims as the three tabs next to it, ads push the sameness to more people, a cleaner site shows it faster, and discounts confirm it was never worth full price. Research on brand choice has found the same thing for decades: the more a brand promotes on price, the more price-sensitive its buyers become.

Every bottle brand sold insulation. Owala sold the lid. Every olive oil poured messily from dark glass. Graza put it in a squeeze bottle. Each answered the complaint the category ignored.

At Montos, we call it the Sameness Delta Protocol. Score. Rebuild. Re-score. It starts with the score. Try one now. Open your homepage. Cover your logo. Read your headline as if your cheapest competitor’s name were on it. If nothing stops being true, that’s one commodity signal. There are 19 more.

That’s the Brand Gap Diagnostic. 20 checks. 3 competitor tabs. 15 minutes. You get your Brand Gap Score out of 40, the leak to fix first, and the Margin Leak Calculator, which shows what your codes cost in dollars. At a 59% margin, a 20% code needs 51% more orders just to make the same profit. The link’s right below me.

Montos started when its founder dropped his own launch over a five-figure branding quote. So the score comes first, before anyone asks you for agency money. 15 minutes. 3 tabs. One honest number. Then you’ll know if you’re the herd, or the llama.

Owala is a registered trademark of Trove Brands, LLC. Graza is a trademark of its owner. Montos is not affiliated with or endorsed by either.

Prefer to read? The whole page is below ↓

Find my commodity signals — $27

One-time payment • Instant access • 30-day guarantee

Brand Gap ScorecardSample
Positioning3/10
Message5/10
Perception5/10
Execution & Offer6/10

19/40

The Discount
Death Spiral

⚑ Red flag: Positioning below Execution

Sample scorecard for an illustrative brand. Yours takes 15 minutes.
Brand Gap ScorecardSample
Positioning3/10
Message5/10
Perception5/10
Execution & Offer6/10

19/40

The Discount Death Spiral

⚑ Red flag: Positioning below Execution

Sample scorecard for an illustrative brand. Yours takes 15 minutes.

( Why it works )

8 years

of household buying data showed it: the more a brand promotes on price, the more price-sensitive its buyers become. See the study ↓

8 brands

escaped their herd the same way, from Owala to YETI: they answered the complaint everyone else ignored. See how ↓

20 checks

run on your own store against three competitor tabs you name, not brands in general.

( 01 · The scene )

It’s 9:02 PM on a Tuesday.

Dinner is done, your partner is watching something in the other room, and you're sitting on the couch with your laptop open to five browser tabs:

adsmanager.facebook.com/adsmanager/manage/campaigns

Cost per purchase today was $52.40. Blended ROAS is sitting at 1.9, down from 3.2 in the spring. Four out of five orders still rely on Meta.

Tab 1 of 5 · click a tab to switch

The last time you ran that 20% code, 38% of that weekend’s orders used it. For the next two weeks, hardly anyone paid full price.

Your cursor is resting on Schedule for Friday at 7:00 AM.

If you send it, you hit your monthly revenue target and give away your remaining margin. If you don't, the copycats take the sales.

You change the subject line twice, close the laptop, and tell yourself it’s the last time you'll discount.

That's what it looks like when buyers see your brand as a commodity.

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

15 minutes. Find out which signal is pushing you into WEEKEND20.

( 02 · What you’ve already tried )

The $51,000downstream hamster wheel

If this feels familiar, it isn't because you haven't tried to fix it. Most founders in this position spend tens of thousands trying to solve this with specialists:

  1. $24,500

    1 · The Meta Ad Agency

    They told you "creative is the new targeting" and ran 12 UGC videos a month. The ads launched at a 1.4% CTR, plummeted to 0.6% three days later, and burned out. Why? The ads sold the general category (a pretty product in morning light) while copycats sold the same visual for less than half the price.

  2. $8,500

    2 · The CRO Freelancer

    They moved the review widget above the fold, made the add-to-cart button sticky, and added Shop Pay. Conversion bumped from 1.8% to 2.0% for a month, then settled at 1.7%. Why? A smoother layout only helped buyers see your $52 price tag faster before clicking over to the cheaper tab.

  3. $18,000

    3 · The Email Retention Agency

    They built complex flows with 15% welcome popups and abandoned-cart discounts. They trained your buyers to wait for codes—which is why 38% of orders used the code the last time it ran.

Each specialist treated the symptom they sell. The ad agency saw a creative problem. The CRO freelancer saw a layout problem. The email agency saw a retention problem.

Agencies sell you more ads. Email agencies sell you more codes. Nobody fixes why buyers can’t tell you apart.

None of them answered the only question a buyer asks with two tabs open:

Why is this one worth $28 more?

( 03 · The real problem )

You cannot out-advertise a commodity signal

The research

Deal-driven buyers react twice as hard to price

Average price sensitivity: how much a 1% price change moves which brand they choose.

Loyal buyers−0.51
Non-loyal buyers−1.02

Over 8 years, as promotions went up and advertising went down, the non-loyal group grew and became more price- and promotion-sensitive.

Mela, Gupta & Lehmann (1997), Journal of Marketing Research 34(2), 248–261. Household panel data for one packaged-goods category, 1984–1992. Read the paper ↗

Think of your brand like a water source. If the spring is muddy, polishing the pipes downstream just gives you cleaner pipes carrying muddy water.

Positioning and perception sit upstream. Ads, CRO, and email sit downstream.

When your product page repeats the same claims as the three tabs next to it ("all-natural," "cold for 24 hours," "premium quality"), your brand sends an unmistakable Commodity Signal.

Every dollar you spend downstream merely amplifies that signal:

UPSTREAM DOWNSTREAM WHAT YOU SAY all-natural cold for 24 hours premium quality The spring positioning + perception Ads push the sameness Site show it faster Offers confirm the price Grey at the source, grey everywhere it flows.

Downstream · Ads

Ads push the sameness to more people.

Downstream · Site

A cleaner site lets them see the sameness faster.

Downstream · Offers

Discounts confirm that your product was never worth full price to begin with.

This isn't a hunch. A long-term study of brand choice found the same thing: the more a brand promotes on price, the more price-sensitive its buyers become. (Mela, Gupta & Lehmann, Journal of Marketing Research, 1997) ↗

Until your brand gives buyers an evidence-backed reason to choose you by name, every marketing dollar you spend is funding the price war.

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

Find your commodity signals in 15 minutes.

( 04 · The antidote )

The Sameness Delta Protocol™

Agencies start brand work with a mood board, a brainstorm, and a list of adjectives like "elevated." Those are the exact same words your competitors came up with in their own rooms.

The Sameness Delta Protocol™ starts with counts and evidence instead:

What 3 competitors claim

all-natural3 of 3
cold for 24 hours3 of 3
premium quality2 of 3
lid that never leaks0 of 3

What their buyers complain about

“The lid leaks in my bag”31% of complaints
“Too heavy to carry all day”18%
“Hard to clean the straw”12%
“Paint chips after a month”9%
The biggest complaint is the one nobody claims to fix. That gap is where your positioning goes. Illustrative example.
  1. STEP 1Score.Run the 20 checks on your store against three competitor tabs. You get your Brand Gap Score out of 40 and the leak to fix first.
  2. STEP 2Rebuild.Fix the leaks yourself, or with the Montos Machines: they count what your competitors claim and what their buyers complain about, then rebuild your position, message, look and offers on the complaint nobody answers.
  3. STEP 3Re-score.Once the changes are live, run the 20 checks again against the same three competitors. Your Brand Gap Score shows what moved.

The pattern behind brands buyers pay more for

The brands that escaped their herd didn't out-advertise it. They answered the complaint everyone else ignored.

Owala.

Everyone sold

Insulation

They answered

Sip through a straw or swig from the spout, in one bottle.

Lid

Graza.

Everyone sold

Dark glass and a messy pour

They answered

A squeeze bottle, and two oils named for what you do with them: Sizzle and Drizzle.

Squeeze

Athletic Brewing.

Everyone sold

Watery non-alcoholic beer that felt like an admission

They answered

One that stands up to craft beer, and makes ordering it something to be proud of.

Taste

Ember.

Everyone sold

Mugs that let coffee go lukewarm

They answered

Coffee held at the temperature you set, sold for $100+ when people said nobody would pay that for a mug.

Heat

Dyson.

Everyone sold

Bags that clog and lose suction

They answered

A bagless vacuum, with "doesn't lose suction" as the whole message.

Suction

OXO.

Everyone sold

Thin metal handles that hurt to hold

They answered

A fat, soft grip, then the same for every tool in the drawer.

Grip

Spanx.

Everyone sold

Pantyhose you cut the feet off to hide panty lines

They answered

They turned that hack into a product.

Hack

YETI.

Everyone sold

Cheap ice chests with handles that broke and lids that caved in

They answered

A cooler tough enough to stand on in a fishing boat, sold for $300+ when most were a fraction of that.

Tough

Owala, Graza, Athletic Brewing, Ember, Dyson, OXO, Spanx and YETI are trademarks of their respective owners. None is affiliated with or endorses Montos. Examples describe each brand's publicly reported product story.

( 05 · Introducing )

The Brand Gap Diagnostic™

The 15-minute scorecard for DTC founders

Created by Montos, The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ is a 20-point diagnostic scorecard that pinpoints the exact signals telling buyers to compare you on price.

Open your store in incognito, open three competitor tabs, and complete this 15-minute diagnostic to see exactly which leaks are suppressing your contribution margin. You finish with your Brand Gap Score out of 40, broken down into Positioning, Message, Perception and Execution & Offer.

Monty presenting the Brand Gap Diagnostic
A page of the PDF scorecard: Part 1, the 20-Point Commodity Audit, with each check and its 0, 1, 2 score boxes Cover of the PDF: The 15-Minute Brand Scorecard
The PDF scorecard · 15 pages · all 20 checks, worded in full
The scoring sheet filled for an example brand: Brand Gap Score 19 out of 40 before, 26 after the re-score, with diagnosis and red flags
Auto-scoring Sheet: your Brand Gap Score, diagnosis, red flags and where to start
The Margin Leak Calculator: 59% margin, 20% discount, 51.3% extra orders needed, with a table by margin and discount
Margin Leak Calculator: a 20% code at a 59% margin needs 51% more orders
The Claims vs Complaints worksheet gap tab: the lid leaks in my bag, 31% of complaints, answered by 0 of 3 competitors
Claims vs. Complaints Worksheet: the complaint nobody answers, ranked

The real files, filled in for an illustrative brand. Your numbers will differ.

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

One-time payment • Instant access • 30-day guarantee

( 06 · Try it now )

Try one check right now. It takes 30 seconds.

Open your homepage. Cover your logo. Read your headline as if your cheapest competitor's name were on it. Does anything stop being true?

If nothing breaks, that's one commodity signal. There are 19 more checks.

YOUR BRAND SHOP · ABOUT · CART

Premium quality you can feel.

All-natural materials. Cold for 24 hours. Made for every day.

Shop now

Illustrative homepage

Press the button to swap in your cheapest competitor’s name.

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

One-time payment • Instant access • 30-day guarantee

( 07 · Before and after )

What changes after 15 minutes

The same Tuesday night, with the diagnostic done.

From a 20% code sitting in drafts to your Brand Gap Score out of 40, the one leak to fix first, and the order to fix it in: Position → Message → Look → Offer.

Monty thinking
Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

One-time payment • Instant access • 30-day guarantee

( Why Montos exists )

Montos started with a detergent sheet brand that never launched. In 2023 the branding quote came back at five figures, and the launch was dropped.

The question stayed. It led to training in brand strategy, and one pattern kept showing up: most product sellers put their effort into the product and the ads, and almost none into the brand. So the copies arrive, the ads cost more, and the discount codes come out.

Montos is the method that founder wanted, and the Machines run it. The Diagnostic is the first step: you see where you look like your competitors, and what it’s costing you, before anyone asks you for agency money.

Monty the llama — Monty

( 08 · What’s inside )

What you get inside the complete diagnostic stack:

Monty pointing at what is inside
01

The 20-Point Commodity Audit

20 live tests across the 4 critical brand gaps: Positioning, Message, Perception, and Execution & Offer. Each check is scored 0 (Commodity), 1 (Average), or 2 (Defensible).

  • TestThe Logo Swap Test: Shows whether your hero headline would still make sense with your competitor's name on it.
  • TestThe Line-Up Test: Shows if a customer can pick your product out of a category lineup with the branding covered.
  • TestThe Flow Test: Audits whether your post-purchase emails build brand status or train discount addiction.
  • FormatDelivered as a PDF scorecard plus an auto-scoring Google Sheet.
$147 value
02

The Margin Leak Calculator

Formulas that translate each brand gap into real dollars using your own numbers:

  • FormulaThe Discount Break-Even: At a 59% margin, see why a 20% discount code requires 51% more order volume just to make the same dollar profit.
  • FormulaThe Perceived Price Ceiling: Calculate the profit you leave on the table every month at the price point you can't currently defend.
  • FormatDelivered as a plug-and-play Google Sheet and Excel file.
$97 value
03

The Diagnosis Matrix & Red Flag Override

An objective diagnosis based on your Brand Gap Score out of 40:

  • 0–20The Discount Death Spiral
  • 21–32The Margin Leak
  • 33–40The Category Sovereign
  • FlagThe Red Flag Detector: Flags critical structural flaws instantly (e.g., when your Execution score is compensating for broken Positioning).
$67 value
04

The Upstream Fix Sequence

A prioritized 1-page action sheet that maps the exact order to fix your leaks (Position → Message → Look → Offer) with a worksheet for your three immediate fixes.

$47 value
BONUS

The Claims vs. Complaints Worksheet

A template and 2-page SOP for collecting and counting competitor claims against customer reviews. Stop brainstorming adjectives in your head and find category whitespace in your buyers' own words.

$97 value

( The real cost )

What WEEKEND20 actually costs

At the numbers in the 9:02 PM scene (about 1,000 orders a month on a $52 product, with 38% using the 20% code, as they did last time), 380 orders a month use the code. That's about $4,000 a month in margin, or nearly $48,000 a year, handed back to buyers who would likely have paid more.

The Diagnostic is $27. Run your own numbers in the Margin Leak Calculator.

Illustrative figures.

The Brand Gap Diagnostic™

TOTAL VALUE $455

Get it today for:

$27

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

One-time payment • Instant access • Auto-calculating sheet included

30 DAY

The 30-Day Margin Guarantee. Don’t find at least three commodity signals? Email us within 30 days for a full refund. You keep everything.

Monty, a llama in a navy blazer and lilac visor, arms crossed

( Monty’s Anti-Herd Law )

"Following the herd is expensive. When every page looks and sounds the same, buyers choose on price, and the herd hands its margin to whoever goes lowest. Own the complaint nobody else answers. I’m a llama in a lilac visor: nobody mistakes me for the alpaca next door."

MontyBrand Strategist at Montos
Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

One-time payment • Instant access • 30-day guarantee

The 30-Day Margin Guarantee

Run your store through the 20 checks against three competitor tabs.

If you don't uncover at least three specific commodity signals on your site that are actively suppressing your margins and training buyers to wait for discounts, email us within 30 days for a full refund.

You keep the audit, the calculator, and the worksheets.

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

30-day guarantee. You keep everything.

( 09 · Questions )

Frequently asked questions

Monty with his hands open, ready for questions
How long does this take to complete?

15 to 20 minutes. Open your site, open three competitor tabs, and score each check 0, 1, or 2.

Do I need a brand strategy or design degree to do this?

No. Every check is something you can see on the page, and three of the 20 work best with a second pair of eyes: someone who doesn’t know your brand. If your hero copy says "all-natural ingredients" and your competitor says "all-natural ingredients," you score a 0 on the Logo Swap Test.

What formats do I receive?

You receive a clean, printable PDF scorecard and an auto-scoring Google Sheet (with an Excel download included).

Will this tell me how to fix the issues it uncovers?

Yes. The Upstream Fix Sequence outlines the order of operations, and the scorecard includes clear guidance on which Montos Machine to use to rebuild your brand yourself.

I sell mainly on Amazon. Does this work?

Yes. Run the checks on your listing instead of your homepage, against the three listings that sit next to yours in search. Your title and first bullet take the Logo Swap Test. Your main image takes the Thumbnail Test, which is built for search results. Your coupons and deals take the discount checks. On Amazon, buyers see you side by side with the copies before they click, so the same signals show up there.

Will fixing this break what already sells?

No. The Diagnostic only scores your store; it doesn’t change anything. A low score doesn’t mean a rebrand. Often the fix is a sharper headline, a different first offer, or a line that answers a buyer’s doubt. Keep what’s working, fix one leak at a time, and re-run the checks to see what moved.

I’m not launching anything. Is this still for me?

Yes. It’s built for stores that are already selling. It scores the store you run today against three competitors, so there’s nothing to launch. You get the lines and offers to change on the store you have.

My product is genuinely better than the copies. Isn't that enough?

Only if a buyer can see it in five seconds. Check 1.5 (The Mechanism) tests exactly that.

What if my score comes back high?

Then you've spent $27 learning your margin problem is somewhere else, and the Fix Sequence tells you where to look. We'd rather tell you that than sell you a rebuild.

Why only $27?

Because it’s the first step, not the fix. Montos exists so you can see the leaks in your store before anyone asks you for agency money.

What happens after I check out?

You get instant access to the PDF scorecard, the auto-scoring Google Sheet, the calculator and the worksheets. Open your store and three competitor tabs, and you can start straight away.

Is this a subscription?

No. One payment of $27. The files are yours to keep.

Can I read instead of watching the video?

Yes. Everything in the video is on this page, and there’s a transcript under the video.

Is this too basic for me?

If you’re doing $300K to $1.5M a year, it’s built for you. The checks are simple to run. The hard part is seeing your own store the way a buyer with two tabs open sees it, and that’s what the score shows you.

I’ve bought things like this before…

Fair. Most of those teach a tactic. This one scores your own store against three competitors you name, so what you get back is about your brand, not brands in general. And if you don’t find at least three commodity signals, the 30-day guarantee gives you your money back.

Find what’s turning your brand into a commodity.

20 checks. 15 minutes. $27.

Get The Brand Gap Diagnostic™ — $27

Instant digital access • PDF scorecard + auto-scoring Google Sheet • 30-day guarantee

Montos

© 2026 Cosmos Avenue Pty Ltd. Montos is a trading name of Cosmos Avenue Pty Ltd. Results vary; figures shown are illustrative. Not financial or legal advice.

Brand Gap Diagnostic
$27 · 30-day guarantee
Get it →